Among the 26 stolen items from Wareham is a 7¼in (cm) high Elizabethan chalice with a parcel gilt interior. The chalice with arabesque patterning and later foot is engraved Lady St Mary and is hallmarked for 1574.

Enjoy unlimited access: just £1 for 12 weeks

Subscribe now

In the space of just two weeks communion silver from churches in Dorset, Suffolk and Lancashire has been taken. The mode of entry and behaviour by the criminals has led to concerns the same gang could be responsible.

Police, insurers and the Church of England have warned other churches to be vigilant.

Thefts from churches had recently focused on stealing lead from roofs but these recent incidents have involved antiques.


A George IV chalice hallmarked for London 1822 and made by Rebecca Emes and Edward Barnard was also stolen from Wareham.

At the Lady St Mary Church in Wareham, Dorset, 26 items were stolen, including the Elizabethan chalice.

Thieves broke a leaded glass window, climbed in and opened the doors from the inside before breaking into every locked door inside the church using angle grinders or a jemmy.

After initial attempts to drill the safe open failed, the burglars used explosives to blow up the locking mechanism. All electrical wires were cut to disable security devices and a lubricant such as WD40 was used to prevent fingerprints being found.


Among the missing items in Wareham was a chalice that belonged to nearby Church of St Nicholas which was being looked after for safekeeping. The silver chalice with applied mercurial gilding is engraved Given to the Church of St. Nicholas at Arne in the Isle of Purbeck by a churchman and is marked JJ & Co, Birmingham and hallmarked for 1868.

Canon Simon Everett said: “I am most grateful to the Antiques Trade Gazette for highlighting this theft and violation of our parish church, and I hope that in doing so at least some of the articles that were stolen may be recovered. We live in hope.”

The Wareham theft took place overnight on April 14-15 and anyone with information should contact Dorset police quoting crime reference number DOR-20230415-0158.

Cross and lectern taken


Among the stolen items at St Mary’s Church in Burstall, Suffolk, was this Victorian cross.

In Suffolk a theft took place between April 9-11 at St Mary’s Church in Burstall, near Hadleigh when a Victorian cross and a lectern were stolen. Anyone with information should contact Suffolk police quoting crime reference number 37/21402/23.

Also in Suffolk, following a burglary at St Michael’s Church in Woolverstone on April 18, a number of items are missing including five brass candlesticks, two brass vases, two small brass organ candelabra and brass candlestick cups. Anyone with information should contact Suffolk police quoting crime reference number 23388/23.

Locks drilled

In Lancashire on April 10-11 at St Mary’s Church in Goosnargh near Preston offenders drilled out the locks on two safes, stole cash and “multiple silverware items of significant value”.

Lancashire Police acknowledged this theft could be linked to similar offences at other churches. A spokesperson said: “We are aware that there have been burglaries at churches in other parts of the country and we are linked in with the forces involved.”

They added: “We ask antiques dealers and those attending antiques fairs and auctions to be vigilant with regards to property which might have been stolen in burglaries at churches.

“If they are suspicious that items they see are stolen, please report it to police. We want to see items returned to their rightful owners.”

A full list of the stolen items from Lady St Mary Church, Wareham is here.